Comments on: Issue of Growing Reservation http://publicmind.in/blog/issue-of-growing-reservation/ Simple and Sophisticated Tue, 07 Feb 2012 08:29:32 +0000 hourly 1 http://wordpress.org/?v=3.3.1 By: Nitin http://publicmind.in/blog/issue-of-growing-reservation/#comment-99 Nitin Mon, 04 May 2009 19:20:14 +0000 http://publicmind.phpzilla.net/?p=4#comment-99 I honor your concern about the management quota, but that does not justify caste based reservation at all. I am against caste based reservation as it (according to me) is the greatest threat to the unity of the nation at the moment. And just because something is legal doesn't means that it is right. Laws change with government and time but not the principles. You can't ask a person, who is against cruelty to dogs to be against cruelty to other animals too. I hope you understand the point. So, "Caste based reservation" tops my list, and I do not consider others to be worth fighting/writing for. Also, I do not agree with your smart-ass line about our hollowness and greed. Actually that makes no sense at all to me, care to explain? And don't you think the road of reservation has become a easy way to get hard things. Why do you ask for admissions into the institute and not good primary and secondary educational facilities ? Because its easier, isn't it!! I honor your concern about the management quota, but that does not justify caste based reservation at all. I am against caste based reservation as it (according to me) is the greatest threat to the unity of the nation at the moment. And just because something is legal doesn’t means that it is right. Laws change with government and time but not the principles.

You can’t ask a person, who is against cruelty to dogs to be against cruelty to other animals too. I hope you understand the point. So, “Caste based reservation” tops my list, and I do not consider others to be worth fighting/writing for.

Also, I do not agree with your smart-ass line about our hollowness and greed. Actually that makes no sense at all to me, care to explain?

And don’t you think the road of reservation has become a easy way to get hard things. Why do you ask for admissions into the institute and not good primary and secondary educational facilities ? Because its easier, isn’t it!!

]]> By: indi http://publicmind.in/blog/issue-of-growing-reservation/#comment-98 indi Mon, 04 May 2009 17:16:23 +0000 http://publicmind.phpzilla.net/?p=4#comment-98 LESS HYPED MANAGEMENT QUOTA [RICH QUOTA] IS WORST Management quota is 1) Illegal [donations are illegal acc. to UGC , and for which they can be deaffiliated ]. 2) It affects more people as private colleges comprise 70% of the total seats. 3) It divides rich and poor people [as u say reservations should be provided to poor, here it is reservation for the rich]. 4) It compromises merit and SC/ST quota acc to u just satisfies last 2 points but its not illegal. BUT STILL SOME PEOPLE PROTEST AGAINST SC/ST QUOTA [EVEN STUDENTS JUSTIFY DISCRIMINATION IN COLLEGES AGAINST SC/STs BECAUSE OF THEIR QUOTA], AND DO NOT RAISE THEIR VOICES AGAINST MANAGEMENT QUOTA. THEY SAY SC/ST DOCTORS ARE NOT CAPABLE OF TREATING PEOPLE AND DO NOT SAY SO FOR MANAGEMENT QUOTA GUYS, WHO BUY SEATS AND GET MBBS DEGREE FROM A PRIVATE COLLEGE RUNNING IN SUBSTANDARD CONDITIONS. THEY DO NOT SAY SO ABOUT DEFENCE GUYS, GOVT QUOTA GUYS , NRI QUOTA GUY'S. IF ACCORDING TO THEM, SC/STs DESERVE DISCRIMINATION BECAUSE OF THEIR QUOTA, WHY DON'T THEY TREAT MANAGEMENT, DEFENCE, GOVERNMENT, HANDICAPPED, AND NRI QUOTA GUYS THIS WAY. MOST ANTI-RESERVATIONISTS MAY NOT KNOW THIS: GOVT QUOTA AND NRI PEOPLE GET SEATS IN CENTRAL COLLEGES WITHOUT EVEN HAVING TO APPEAR FOR THE ENTRANCE EXAMS. HANDICAPPED QUOTA MERIT LIST GOES LOWER THAN SC/ST QUOTA AND DEFENCE QUOTA MERIT IS SOMETIMES LOWER , AND MOST TIMES AROUND SC QUOTA. THIS SHOWS THE HOLLOWNESS AND GREED OF ANTI-RESERVATIONISTS. LESS HYPED MANAGEMENT QUOTA [RICH QUOTA] IS WORST

Management quota is

1) Illegal [donations are illegal acc. to UGC , and for which they can be deaffiliated ].
2) It affects more people as private colleges comprise 70% of the total seats.
3) It divides rich and poor people [as u say reservations should be provided to poor, here it is reservation for the rich].
4) It compromises merit and SC/ST quota acc to u just satisfies last 2 points but its not illegal.

BUT STILL SOME PEOPLE PROTEST AGAINST SC/ST QUOTA [EVEN STUDENTS JUSTIFY DISCRIMINATION IN COLLEGES AGAINST SC/STs BECAUSE OF THEIR QUOTA], AND DO NOT RAISE THEIR VOICES AGAINST MANAGEMENT QUOTA. THEY SAY SC/ST DOCTORS ARE NOT CAPABLE OF TREATING PEOPLE AND DO NOT SAY SO FOR MANAGEMENT QUOTA GUYS, WHO BUY SEATS AND GET MBBS DEGREE FROM A PRIVATE COLLEGE RUNNING IN SUBSTANDARD CONDITIONS. THEY DO NOT SAY SO ABOUT DEFENCE GUYS, GOVT QUOTA GUYS , NRI QUOTA GUY’S. IF ACCORDING TO THEM, SC/STs DESERVE DISCRIMINATION BECAUSE OF THEIR QUOTA, WHY DON’T THEY TREAT MANAGEMENT, DEFENCE, GOVERNMENT, HANDICAPPED, AND NRI QUOTA GUYS THIS WAY.
MOST ANTI-RESERVATIONISTS MAY NOT KNOW THIS:
GOVT QUOTA AND NRI PEOPLE GET SEATS IN CENTRAL COLLEGES WITHOUT EVEN HAVING TO APPEAR FOR THE ENTRANCE EXAMS. HANDICAPPED QUOTA MERIT LIST GOES LOWER THAN SC/ST QUOTA AND DEFENCE QUOTA MERIT IS SOMETIMES LOWER , AND MOST TIMES AROUND SC QUOTA.
THIS SHOWS THE HOLLOWNESS AND GREED OF ANTI-RESERVATIONISTS.

]]>